Editorial: Instaurare et Reparare
by Duncan G. Stroik, appearing in Volume 50
Every year in November we celebrate two great basilicas in the same town, buildings which were built in ancient times and rebuilt in modern times. This year is special because it is the 1700th anniversary of the construction of a small church by Constantine over the body of Saint Paul around 326 and the 400th anniversary of the reconstruction by the popes of the great church over the body of Saint Peter in 1626. From the earliest days these two great basilicas have been compared to one another while being seen as a pair, reflecting the fact that Christian Rome is a city of Peter and Paul. Both basilicas were rebuilt since the Renaissance but under different theories of reconstruction, resulting in two magnificent but different sacred places.
According to tradition, Saint Peter’s was built as one of the largest buildings of the Roman Empire by the Constantinian emperors. They also built Saint Paul’s, but as a smaller chapel. Sixty years later, the emperors rebuilt Saint Paul’s on the scale of Saint Peter’s, but better. Many centuries later, around 1500, Saint Peter’s was on the verge of collapse, leading to suggestions of rebuilding. In 1823, Saint Paul’s actually collapsed when a great fire destroyed the huge roofs and wood trusses, leading to the destruction of much of the 290-foot-long north nave wall and its twenty monolithic fluted marble columns. In drawings made right after the fire, Saint Paul’s appears like an ancient ruin.
In 1506, Pope Julius II and his architect Bramante decided to do a major renovation of the ancient church of Saint Peter’s with a new transept, apse and huge dome over the crossing. Over the next 100 years many popes and great architects renovated and added on to the ancient basilica until Pope Paul V gave the direction to Maderno to tear down the nave and rebuild it in keeping with the dome. This series of renovations led in 1626 to the dedication of a wholly new church. Today, the church we see remembers the width of the original nave while being twice as long plus the addition of a barrel-vaulted ceiling. The giant paired Corinthian pilasters and arches are three times as large as the ancient basilica’s columns. Like the original Saint Peter’s, the monumental new building is built around the tomb of the first pope, and on top of the foundations of the basilica built 1300 years before. At the time it was called an instauratio (restoration) although we would call it a renovation and replacement.
Saint Paul’s Outside the Walls, which was of a similar size and only slightly younger than the original Saint Peter’s also had its share of additions and modifications but it was constructed more solidly than old Saint Peter’s. However, on the night of July 15, 1823, a great fire burnt the roof and one of the main interior walls of the church. Modern scholars are not sure how the fire was started, and why it was not noticeable until 1:40 in the morning. The client, in this case Pope Leo XII, acted immediately and called for a faithful reconstruction in pristinum: “It is Our firm purpose that the sacred monument erected over the tomb of the Doctor of the Gentiles be raised again from its ashes, preserving as far as possible the form and glory of its original structure, so that future generations may behold the same sanctuary in which their ancestors prayed.”
The pope’s stated intention was to rebuild Saint Paul’s the way it was in 386. However, literal restoration is much more difficult than it sounds as there are many design decisions to be made. The basilica had developed over the centuries and had received additional altars and artwork, including a beautiful Gothic baldacchino which survived the fire, while other elements such as the atrium were gone. What to do about these? The destruction and damage to the ancient fluted marble columns and arches meant that new elements would have to be fabricated to replace them. The architects argued over how to make these, and in the end they chose to modify the interior with hundreds of new columns made in granite rather than marble and employing Corinthian capitals inspired by the Pantheon. New artwork was also commissioned on the walls, though inspired by the style of the originals. The new trusses were covered with a glorious coffered ceiling, a new bell tower was constructed, and the atrium garden was fully rebuilt.
Today we would call Saint Peter’s a renovation (or new) and Saint Paul’s a restoration, and yet the building projects share a number of things in common. While Saint Paul’s sought to restore the original five-aisled basilica plan, Saint Peter’s remembers aspects of its five-aisled plan, which can be seen in architectural drawings. The construction sites cramped these great pilgrimage churches for many decades, and prevented great crowds from gathering there. New columns were fabricated to be placed where they had been before at Saint Paul’s, while at Saint Peter’s the huge number of colorful marble and granite columns were reused in new locations—at the entrance loggia, in side aisles, in side chapels, and even on the Acqua Paola on the Janiculum Hill. Other elements such as the white Solomonic marble columns of the altar screen became frames for the four great reliquaries at the corners of the majestic new dome. When they were rebuilt, both projects gave us new buildings that were better than what they had been previously, while preserving and remembering aspects of art and architecture from their millenial history.
In the city of Saints Peter and Paul, there were two great apostolic basilicas constructed in the saints’ memory and over their bodies. Today, the buildings on these holy sites are relatively recent constructions but remind us of their antiquity. They also remind us of these two apostles who came to evangelize the greatest city in the world, and came to martyrdom. Their teaching and death had a great effect on the conversion of the Roman Empire and later the world, and these two buildings are witnesses to that. They are also witnesses to the ways we rebuild, whether as a renovation and replacement, or as a faithful restoration. The rebuilding of the Basilicas of Saints Peter and Paul employed the finest architects and artists of their time, led by holy popes who believed that sacred architecture was necessary to honor the saints, and promote the faith.